Friday, October 19, 2007

Why care?

I have been part of numerous San Francisco Bay Area choral start-ups over the last 4 years. These projects spanned the entire amateur-professional spectrum, in terms of artistry. While, in each case, the music making was deeply rewarding, the box-office returns were more often than not, disappointing, if not disastrous. No classical music start-up can survive purely on the concert-revenue-driven business model. Things are harder for us than for our pop musician compatriots.

All classical music groups eventually recognize that outside support is an absolute necessity in these endeavors. Fund-raising and grant-seeking take up a large fraction of the effort of a non-profit arts organization. Our colleagues across the Atlantic still benefit from relatively generous support from State-funded agencies. Here, in the U.S.A., we scour the sidewalks for $50 here and there from friends, $500 from various foundations, hoping and praying that some former oil baron will send us that magical 5-figure check needed to bankroll most professional projects.

If we were to succeed in raising all of the external support necessary to produce a concert, the ghost of Adam Smith would still whisper in my ear, "Why go through all the effort if no one is going to consume your product?" In less technocratic terms, why put on a performance if no one out there wants to share in the experience? An empty house is emotionally devastating and demoralizing. What are we trying to do? Are we trying to force the public to buy typewriters and horse-drawn buggies when they really want iPhones and SUV's? Are classical choral concerts going the way of the Vaudeville show?

My classical music friends and I are fighting this rising tide of disappointment. We are guided by one simple principle. If we are passionate about this art-form, then it must have the possibility of resonating with the wider public. The question is, how.


Anonymous said...


I heartily support what you're doing here!

I come at this issue from a slightly different perspective. It's my belief that the MAIN reason choral music is arguably a dying art is that most choirs are full of singers who aren't connecting dynamically to the music or to the audience.

Unfortunately, far too many choral directors expect their singers to stand still and focus on the technical aspects of the music. Well, 60 singers standing still and singing with little expression or connection to text is (to my mind) about 60 times less interesting than ONE soloist who sings without passion or personal connection to text or music. I say, "A chorus shouldn't bore us," but the current paradigm of choral performance unfortunately does just that.

For those reasons, I wrote a book which directly addresses the issue, and I travel around the country doing clinics with choirs, helping them engage dynamically with music and audience. The book is called "Choral CHARISMA: Singing with Expression," and my website is, should anyone be curious.

I look forward to reading more on this blog. (:-)



Blogger said...

If you want your ex-girlfriend or ex-boyfriend to come crawling back to you on their knees (no matter why you broke up) you need to watch this video
right away...

(VIDEO) Have your ex CRAWLING back to you...?

Blogger said...

You could be eligible for a complimentary Apple iPhone 7.